I discussed on Twitter a while ago one of the difficulties I’m having running
the musl version of Void Linux: some applications just don’t work on musl. Text
editors, specifically. I normally use Sublime, but it being a proprietary editor
means that it won’t work on musl without the developers adding support (which is
something they’ve been asked to do a few times, with no response ever given).
So I tried to use Atom, which is open source! Except it completely obfuscates
the process of downloading dependencies to the point that it deletes them when
the build finishes, even if it finished by failing, and one dependency uses the
basename function in a way that doesn’t work on musl. The fix for that would
actually be pretty easy… if I could actually edit the dependency. I eventually
decided to try Kate, which doesn’t seem like a bad text editor, but just isn’t
what I’m used to. I then didn’t ever really use it, because I only run Void on
my laptop, and I haven’t actually sat down to work on the project I’m working on
in a while.
But today I wanted to write a post here about an issue I ran into this week, and I figured I could use this laptop for that instead of rebooting my desktop to Ubuntu just to write a blog post. And then when I actually sat down to start writing that, I didn’t even open Kate; I spent most of today trying to a) make a desktop environment other than xfce work (I’m on cinnamon now) and b) find and build a text editor that might be closer to what I’m used to. When that didn’t work, I tried to set up a glibc chroot and run Sublime, or Atom, or any of the other editors I tried in that; that also didn’t work for any of them. But one editor I tried had instructions to run it in Docker, and though that didn’t work, I decided to see if there was any way to do that with Atom. And there is!
Running Atom in Docker
Turns out that James Netherton has already created a public Docker container that lets you run Atom in Docker. The README, however, is somewhat lacking, and didn’t actually work for me, so here’s what I found works:
- Install Docker (on Void, with
sudo xbps-install -S docker).
- If you want things to be slightly easier, add yourself to the docker group.
On Void, use
usermod -aG docker your_username. This is obviously a security risk and, given how the Docker container is set up, should be wholly unnecessary. I, however, threw security to the wind and added myself anyway. Should you have any issues trying to do this while running Docker with sudo, I’d be glad to try and help solve them.
- Add yourself to the xhost access list, so that the container can open a
window on your physical machine:
If you’re on a system that doesn’t have systemd, then add these lines to your /etc/rc.local (and either run them or reboot):
mkdir /sys/fs/cgroup/systemd mount -t cgroup -o none,name=systemd cgroup /sys/fs/cgroup/systemd
This is necessary for Docker to work at all; otherwise it will error out.
Pull the Docker container:
docker pull jamesnetherton/docker-atom-editor.
Create and start the Docker container:
docker run -d --name atom \ --user=$(id -u) \ --env="DISPLAY" \ --workdir="$HOME" \ --volume="$HOME:$HOME" \ --volume="/etc/group:/etc/group:ro" \ --volume="/etc/passwd:/etc/passwd:ro" \ --volume="/etc/shadow:/etc/shadow:ro" \ --volume="/tmp/.X11-unix:/tmp/.X11-unix:rw" \ --volume="/dev/shm:/dev/shm" \ jamesnetherton/docker-atom-editor
This does a few things that the command in the README doesn’t:
- Override the user specified in the Dockerfile to be yourself
- Mount your home directory in the container so that you can edit all your
files (and keep the Atom config files persistent). You can change what you
mount here, but keep if you do want to further limit what you mount, make
sure you at least mount your .atom directory to
$HOME/.atom, otherwise you’ll lose configuration persistence. In my situation, I’m fine mapping my entire home directory since I have nothing sensitive on this laptop, but if you have your own concerns this is the most flexible part of the setup.
- Mount the group/passwd/shadow/X11 files from your system to the container, in order for a) permissions to make sense and b) allow step 3 to work (per the Open Source Robotics Foundation).
The README works, but only if you turn off access control to your X server and do some other mapping to be able to open files and store your config (and the command in the README might require some fudging of permissions if you aren’t user 1000).
That’s it! Atom should open and you should be able to browse your home folder. When you close Atom, it will stop the Docker container. To relaunch Atom, you’ll only need to run
docker start atom.
(Added the day after I published this post) If you reboot, then your X server shuts down, and if your X server shuts down, the access control changes you made with
xhostare lost. To solve that, either re-run
xhost +SI:localuser:$USERevery time you reboot, or make it happen when X starts:
echo "xhost +SI:localuser:$USER" >> ~/.xprofile. This still isn’t a big security concern; it only allows your user, with your credentials, to connect to the X server.
This is, as far as I can tell, probably the most secure way to run this Docker container. You don’t open your X11 server up to connections from anywhere, which was a big issue with the only instructions I could find for running this, and you still get a working installation of Atom where it otherwise wouldn’t work. If you run into any issues, feel free to reach out on Twitter and I can try to help you with them.